Would You Rather: Be in a plane crash or Be in a train crash?
Would you rather Be in a plane crash or Be in a train crash? "Be in a plane crash" or "Be in a train crash" — neither option is desirable, so the real question is which is less terrible. What does "Be in a plane crash" actually feel like up close? Not in the abstract, but in the Tuesday afternoon version of it. The version where the initial thrill or shock has worn off and you are just living with it. That is where the real test of this choice lies. The extreme angle adds another layer because these questions are never purely personal — they ripple outward into how you relate to others. "Be in a train crash" deserves the same scrutiny. At first, it might seem like the safer or more reasonable option. But safety has its own costs. Choosing this path means closing the door on what "Be in a plane crash" offered, and over time, that closed door can become the thing you think about most. In extreme dilemmas specifically, the option that seems less dramatic often turns out to be more life-altering in practice. The real tension here is not between "Be in a plane crash" and "Be in a train crash" as isolated options. It is between two different visions of who you want to be. Our community has voted on this 6,682 times, and the split — roughly 52% for the first option.